Skip to main content

Our response to the Milburn Review

Tags:
  • Other resource types
  • Mental health and wellbeing
  • Poverty and cost of living
  • 2026
Author:

Kate Roberts ,

Date:
Read time:
7 minutes

The Milburn Review intro

Milburn review 5050
The Milburn Review is right to demand change, but young people need more than another route into treatment 

Today’s Review on young people not in employment, education or training (NEET) lands at a time when young people feel increasingly uncertain about their future. While the growing number of young people outside education, employment and training is rightly attracting attention, there is a risk that the debate exacerbates the stress and fear amongst young people for their future. Young people are being let down by systems that have failed to keep pace with the challenges they are facing.  

Most unhappy in europe

Fifteen-year-olds in the UK report some of the lowest levels of life satisfaction in Europe. Too many children and young people struggle to access support when they need it, while pressures relating to the cost of living, safety, housing, discrimination, the climate crisis, educational stress and concerns about the future all combine to undermine wellbeing and erode hope.

Moving beyond single explanations

One of the strengths of the Milburn Review is that it avoids the frequent mistake of searching for a single explanation. Rather, the Review accurately points out that the barriers to getting young people into worthwhile education, employment or training are complex and interconnected. Opportunities that previous generations took for granted have become harder to access. Many Saturday jobs aren’t what they used to be, such as the paper round or a Saturday job in a local shop. How many of these exist now? That first step into employment is integral to improve confidence, experience and independence, but the availability and opportunity is so low. At the same time, young people are navigating a more uncertain economic landscape, and the ongoing threat that AI poses to the job market.

The Review makes clear that the challenges facing young people have increased and grown more complex, while Government has failed to shift support systems to reflect this.  

As we found in our Meet Me Where I Am report published earlier this year, access to mental health support is not evenly distributed, with some children and young people much more likely to come up against barriers to access. The system is difficult to navigate and often children reach crisis point before they can access support. 

Young people are facing immense challenges. The extent to which those challenges are driving the rise in young people becoming NEET, or whether being outside education, employment and training is itself worsening these challenges, is difficult to disentangle. But what is clear is that things cannot continue as they are. Too many young people are struggling with poor wellbeing, unmet mental health needs and declining confidence in their future prospects. That is why we welcome the ambition in the Milburn Review. There is a reason that this Review has transcended beyond discourse solely on employment, education and training - and that is because it gets to the heart of a needed shift in support for young people.

Why early support is vital

Why early support is vital

The Review’s recognition of the role that mental health plays in young people’s participation in education and employment is welcome. Encouragingly, it reflects a growing consensus following the Fonagy Review that support should be based on young people’s needs, rather than waiting for a formal diagnosis. The challenge now is ensuring that implementation goes beyond treatment alone. Alongside improving access to care, policymakers must also address the conditions that are causing young people to struggle in the first place. 

Milburn review 5050

Early support

We know that incremental improvements will not be enough; what we need is a fundamental shift towards a system of support that is preventative and built around the realities of young people’s lives today. The Government needs to view young people as their whole selves, rather than defining their success purely through participation in education or employment. Not only are young people more than just a pupil, patient or potential employee, but by viewing young people – in both policymaking and service delivery – as an actual whole person, enables their potential to thrive, including as a pupil and future employee. 

Early support is one of the smartest investments we can make for young people. Our report with PBE earlier this year found a £14 return for every £1 the Government in invests in early support, creating significant cost savings for the public over time. Prevention is not simply the right thing to do for young people; it is also a more effective use of public resources than waiting until problems have become entrenched. Investment in early support should not depend on withdrawing support from vulnerable young people before alternatives are in place. 

Joining up support

We know that incremental improvements will not be enough; what we need is a fundamental shift towards a system of support that is preventative and built around the realities of young people’s lives today. The Government needs to view young people as their whole selves, rather than defining their success purely through participation in education or employment. Not only are young people more than just a pupil, patient or potential employee, but by viewing young people – in both policymaking and service delivery – as an actual whole person, enables their potential to thrive, including as a pupil and future employee. 

Early support is one of the smartest investments we can make for young people. Our report with PBE earlier this year found a £14 return for every £1 the Government in invests in early support, creating significant cost savings for the public over time. Prevention is not simply the right thing to do for young people; it is also a more effective use of public resources than waiting until problems have become entrenched. Investment in early support should not depend on withdrawing support from vulnerable young people before alternatives are in place. 

Reducing NEET numbers shouldn't be the only goal

The Review is understandably concerned about the growing number of young people outside education, employment and training, but reducing those numbers should not become the sole measure of success. Some young people will always experience periods outside education, employment or training because of illness, caring responsibilities, transitions or other life circumstances.  

To test our own critical skills, we should always be asking ‘why?’ Why do we want better job prospects? Why do we want a healthier economy? To what end? The destination should be that we get to a place in society where everyone is living a happy, healthy and fulfilled life and with a hope for the future. So, by that measure and challenge, it is the wellbeing of young people that can be both the ultimate measure, as well as the driver of other improved outcomes. Improving young people’s wellbeing and helping them to build lives in which they can thrive is a much more impactful outcome. A young person who feels supported and optimistic is far more likely to sustain participation in education and employment over the long term than one who is simply moved from one programme or intervention to another. 

The Review is right to be thinking outside of the box. Something needs to change because the status quo is unacceptable. What Milburn gets right is recognising that, and recognising that the solution isn’t just to create a conveyor belt where a young person gets carried through education, lands a job and then progresses through their career. It isn’t a simple and linear line. A young person’s engagement with education, training and work, is no different to all of our engagement with those things, it is shaped by the world around us, by other circumstances and opportunities.  

The Government must take that on board when they continue to engage on this issue – there is no neat solution to the NEET crisis. It requires a fundamental shift in the support available for young people. 

Agreeing with the review

Milburn review 5050

We agree with the Review in its calls for the Government to invest in support for mental health, alongside prevention, trusted adults, youth workers, activities for young people and community infrastructure, and creating services that are easy to access and designed around young people's lives. The Review leaves questions about the route to a more joined up system, particularly where new initiatives such as the Youth Opportunity Service are added to the landscape of support. The real test of the Review will be whether it helps create a system that prevents young people from experiencing low wellbeing in the first place and supports young people earlier when needs do arise. Young people do not need a better route through fragmented systems; they need a different system altogether.